The Top 10 Metal of 2012 - The Honorable Mentions

I'm not exactly a traditionalist but here I sit, writing the third instalment of the Crushtor.net Top 10 of Metal, this time for the year 2012. What seems a mammoth gap between 2011 and 2012 astounds even me. I'm often forced to think hard about my position as a man in 2011 in relation to today. My aspiration to find employment as a music writer has thankfully come into fruition. I'm being sent greater numbers of promos from an array of genres than I've ever had before, each one jumping up to occupy my dwindling amounts of time to review them with the diligence and attention they deserve.

The year began with a slow burn. Bizzaro masters Sigh released a chillingly admirable follow-up to 2010's Scenes From Hell, In Somniphobia. Hipster darlings Alcest continued their black metal world conquest apace with Les Voyages de L'Ame. These discs among others were stellar - four or five star records - but neither made my list. This isn't an excoriation on their quality, they were simply edged out by some monumentally brilliant cuts. Release schedules picked up pace after July, betraying a store of label pocket aces, all in gleeful foreknowledge of what treasures they'd bestow unto us later in 2012. That's why I've expanded the list to a maximum of 20, in full view of the many praiseworthy efforts on offer. However, like every year I shall begin with the Honorable Mentions, three discs earning the Gold, Silver and Bronze awards respectively.

A hush sweeps over the audience as the Bronze Award is presented...

Kamelot - Silverthorn

In the year 2004 I, a Year 12 student with a B+ grade average in English inadvertently wound up on Finnish prog label Lion Music's distro list, goaded into filing praise-filled copy in the service of their artists. With the business model "Sign ten and hope one of them turns a profit" greying and in its death throes, progressive power metal act Seventh Wonder with silver-tongued Tommy Karevik front and center was their hope to balance their running deficits, seeing their budget routinely blown on raising an army of Dream Theater and Yngwie Malmsteen clones. To quote me, circa 2006 or so: "Mr. Karevik is a rare find - To compare him to his contemporaries, he is a mix of a less self-conscious Mac (Threshold), while his theatrical smooth yet powerful baritone reminds one of Mr. Roy Khan (Kamelot)." Fittingly, he swept his Uther away to become the revered Arthur of Kamelot.  Surrounded by gallant sonic knights, Karevik wills the fantastic and bombastic back into power metal. Upon flights of baleful libretto and swathes of romantic strings, Kamelot evoke a pure, heartfelt nostalgia for thousands of tales of boyhood adventure both magical and arcane. 

Trembling and sweating, a sigh of relief is audible throughout the stadium with the Silver Award handed to...

Paradise Lost - Tragic Idol

In exclaim!, the premier Canadian street press, guitarist Greg(or) Mackintosh delineated previous record Faith Divides Us, Death Unites Us from the superb Tragic Idol: "Faith would be quite a bitter, dark cake with lots of layers and plenty of icing. Tragic Idol would be a simple, delicious, moist cake with no icing." True enough. There's no lolling about so it's gratifyingly devoid of orchestral or synthetic garland threatening their fatalistic poetry. Scintillating, unvarnished doom metal rivaling the gilded mid-90s era is the result. Unfettered cruelty from both riff and throat blasts blackness and anguish into the gelid hearts of desperate men. Comparatively, My Dying Bride thinks more is best. But hey - they aren't on this list, are they?

Whoops and cheers break out as we shake the hands of the Gold Award winners, holding their trophy aloft...

 


Daylight Dies - A Frail Becoming

Vocalist Nathan Ellis emailed me a few weeks ago. The missive contained a profuse apology – the new discs had been misplaced and it would be a few weeks more until they arrived. Roger and Jaymz of 3CR radio's The Heavy Session played an elegantly brutal cut from the album while I co-hosted last Sunday. From then on, the wait grew unbearable. On the Monday, it finally appeared. Thrusting the disc into my beefy rig following a harrowing corporate Christmas party, my breath was taken by their vulnerable, inspired doom-weighted odes. The album replete with bounding textures and ever-shifting dark expressions of inner torment envelops you in the searing heat of their dispassion. It’s prosaic to suggest that Daylight Dies’ fingertips have merely brushed greatness, closing the gap between on each album – yet true enough. Now they can stand proudly as their calloused, withered hands clutch their well-deserved prize.

We announce to the prizeless to stick around, as we prepare to proclaim the latter half of the Top 20 of 2012.


14. Diablo Swing Orchestra - Pandora's Pinata
15. Black Breath -
Sentenced to Life
16. Enslaved -
Riitiir
17. Between the Buried and Me -
Parallax II: Future Sequence
18. Wintersun -
Time I
19. Gojira -
L'Enfant Sauvage
20. Twelve Foot Ninja -
Silent Machine

With the formalities dispensed with, we can look forward to the Top 10...

View the Top 10 of 2010
View the Top 10 of 2011

Article: Top 10 inarguably terrible music genres (TheVine)

Originally titled "Top 10 boils on the arse of music (that eventually went away)"

---

We've all been there.You find yourself at a party finding your face gurned into a deformed pumpkin as it bears witness to a bunch of people dancing to music so heinous it ought to be banned by the Geneva Convention. "It's Dubstep," they'll peep, "It's everything that's great about music right now."* Brimming with more scepticism than a James Randi convention, you clamour for a bunker in which your own music collection is lowered into to, wait until the plague flushes through the intertubes. Once the toxicity fades proper music is allowed to flourish once again.

Luckily, when it comes to these musical aberrations, our consensus realities are in agreement for about as long as a lunchbreak at a Student Union committee meeting ("Lunch is oppressive, I propose that we serve organic vegan lunch from now on" implore the Communists for Disabled Whales faction) and it only takes a few months (or days in this day and age) to initiate a ritual cleansing of any unpalatable music style. So what are the top 10 boils on the arse of music that, when left untreated and ignored thankfully vanished of their own accord?

 

*This has probably never happened ever.

Read the entire list at TheVine.

Interview: Alex Webster of Cannibal Corpse

This interview was conducted in September 2012.

---

The mental effort to envision a death metal world without Cannibal Corpse would invariably leave exploded cortical entrails that would be found miles away – in fact, the mere act itself makes perfect fodder for one of their ‘intentionally frightening’ songs. Pounding stages just shy of a quarter of a century, Cannibal Corpse has almost become a synecdoche for American and indeed global death metal. In this interview, founding bassist Alex Webster reveals the quintessence of brutal death metal.
 

Hi, Alex. Where are you at the moment?

I’m home in Tampa, FL right now.

Your top 5 records or ‘desert island discs’ Restless and Wild by Accept, Morbid Angel’s Alters of Madness, Master of Puppets, Powerslave, Reign in Blood; all metal, but diverse choices as well. How do those discs shape your playing and songwriting?

Probably in ways in which I couldn’t explain. It’s just, that kind of stuff, if you look at most of those records that I listed was the stuff I was listening to in the 80s when I was just becoming a musician. I think I started playing bass around 1984 and right around that time I was listening to Accept and Iron Maiden and Metallica and Slayer and all those things I listed.

Morbid Angel was probably the newest release on the list, from 1989 I think. So all those discs were from the 80s and they all had a very big impact on me as a musician. Both as a songwriter and a bass player…and some places in particular, Steve Harris from Iron Maiden is someone whom I look up to a lot, Peter from Accept as well is really another influence. I like David Vincent’s bass playing a lot too…the bass solo in Suffocation was one of my favourites. It’s a big influence on my writing and me as a musician. I couldn’t explain exactly how, but I’m sure it works its way in there. Those metal records are my idea of what good metal records should be, songwriting and musicianship wise.

Your idea of 'what good metal should be', can you explain that?

Well, we've never been very good at imitating the bands we like. Like on Eaten Back to Life, I remember certain sections of that, or riffs or whatever we might have been thinking about one particular band when we were writing one of the riffs...maybe not one of the riffs but we would think 'let's make a part like something Dark Angel would do or what Slayer would do' or whatever. We never tried imitating bands and it winds up being your own style. As far as imitating or emulating, we're not that good at it. The overall attitude and commitment to excellence that the bands I mentioned have, that's what inspires us.

Slayer and Iron Maiden in particular. For standard heavy metal Iron Maiden are extremely consistent in the way they present themselves as a band. Their logo has stayed the same, they've had similar album covers, they have very consistent music - I definitely like some of their albums a lot more than others - but they're all heavy metal albums. The same with Slayer; all their albums are thrash metal, except maybe Diabolus in Musica was a little 'whatever' but most of their records are very consistent too. Again, they have that consistency in image. Those are two bands we've looked up to a lot: me personally for sure. The other guys have admired the consistency those other bands have shown too. I think that's a big part of heavy metal; being dependable and consistent.

When bands stray too far outside their niche and there's a backlash, do you think consistency is the key?

I think it's a very big part of it. Unless you're an experimental metal band by nature people don't really want that experimentation by nature, I don't think. They want us to try and out do what they've done - I don't think people want us to stand still and put out the same album again and again but I think what they want is something stylistically consistent and hopefully even a little better than the last album. When bands go too far away from their style it's generally not well received in the metal community; it might be well received insofar it's part of that genre. In metal, consistency is a big part of our genre and sticking to your original plans as a band. When bands don't do that it's not always well received.

Your father once had old 50s records which inspired you to pick up the guitar and eventually the bass. Being in a musical family, do you think your becoming a musician was almost an inevitability?

I think it helped. My father was in a bagpipe band, having a little bit of Scottish heritage on his side of the family. He was really interested in that kind of music, so he got involved with one of those bands when I was very young...I was about three when he began playing the pipes. He picked it up fairly quickly and the band would play songs that weren't overly difficult. Just standard parade songs and they would go do parades and that. So when I grew up, all summer long, the family would be going to all these various small cities around the west of New York area and my father's band would be performing at these various different carnivals. You know, festivals and other things they would be having and my father's band would play there. So I grew up around that kind of music.

My mother had taught herself to play piano by ear, so I do think music is something in our 'genes,' for sure...a proclivity for music on both sides of the family. Both of my brothers played in the brass band in school, they were actually trumpet players. They didn't follow up a music career; I'm the only one who did. But music was in our whole family.

You've said that Cannibal Corpse is like the Evil Dead of death metal – would it be fair to suggest you’re winking at the audience while scaring the shit out of them?

Well, it depends. We've really tried hard to make our songs serious horror songs. But the ones that have the more extreme gore in them, those lyrics kind of make the audience realise there's a bit of black humour to it, much in the way the Evil Dead or the Evil Dead II did. Those movies were meant to be frightening, for sure. But it takes some of the scare out of it because they were so over the top. None of the songs are written to be intentionally humourous or anything like that, but I think when you're describing somebody that bloody considering the context; it's in a band. It's in a band and you're enjoying the music and you're reading the lyrics that's describing something completely atrocious, you know, people aren't going to take it particularly seriously.

When it's something a little darker...it's strange, but if you edge a little off the gore and the song becomes more frightening. I think you can find that in horror movies too. I would say Cannibal Corpse has a little bit of Evil Dead to it, but we have more serious kind of horror songs too. Not that any of them were intentionally not serious. But I think when you edge the gore back a little bit and leave something to the listener's imagination you can wind up with something a bit more frightening. That's the same way with horror movies, I think. The movies that I found to be the most frightening weren't particularly graphic, as far as violence goes. The Exorcist, The Shining. They're two of my favourite horror movies but they weren't particularly violent. Burnt Offerings, The Sentinel. There's a number of dark, frightening movies that I really like and they aren't that gory at all. We have songs that are Evil Dead-like but we have songs that are more like The Shining.

Bands like Lazarus A.D. and Evile are leading an American-style thrash metal revival - do you think we'll see an American death metal revival in the same vein?

I think the difference between the thrash metal genre and the death metal genre is that death metal has been ongoing whereas with thrash metal you have this big drop off where it was really big and a lot of the bands started doing different things and broke up and what not where as death metal has been ongoing. There's no need for a 'revival' because it hasn't gone away.

I can show you very distinct examples of it being around for a long time. Like, in 1983 you have Possessed come out. A couple of years later you have Death release Scream Bloody Gore a couple years later, Morbid Angel release Altars of Madness and then us, then after that you have Hypocrisy, a couple years after that you have Nile putting out an album, shortly after that Krisiun put out an album, Angelcorpse put out a record and you have Eon come on the scene and bands like that, so there's been bands throughout. Deeds of Flesh came out in the mid-90s. It's not so strictly defined by one small period of time, it's been an ongoing thing with a steady scene and we can attest to that with the tours that we've done. We've been doing really brutal death metal tours right along for over twenty years now. If there was a revival it would be kind of redundant because it's not something that needs to be revived! [laughs]

It's different to thrash because you can kind of pinpoint the mid-80s as the heyday of thrash and a lot of that stuff was a really far out style for a long time and the bands coming back are doing a great job of playing that kind of music. But there's like this big gap where for twenty years there wasn't a whole lot going on in thrash metal, it's not like what was happening in death metal.

The band was featured recently on [cable news network] MSNBC as “the” death metal band and you appeared in the documentary film Metal: A Headbangers’ Journey which was well received. Do you think Cannibal Corpse are death metal’s unofficial ambassadors to the world?

[taken aback] Oh boy, that’s a pretty big responsibility! I think I might be one of the guys that do some decent interviews and the other guys in the band that represents our genre well. But there are plenty of other guys out there that do a great job in representing our genre. We being the most well-known band at the moment we probably get a lot of these interviews before some of the other bands do. It kind of compounds itself I guess. You become the biggest band over a period of time and you get these opportunities to get this sort of press to make you even bigger. I think we’re good representatives but there’s plenty of other good ones too. David Vincent always does good interviews; Steve from Deicide, the guys from Immolation. There are a lot of articulate musicians in this scene that give great interviews. I think we might be above them but we’re certainly not the only ones.

How has your personality changed over the last almost 25 years and how does that come out in your music?

I’m sure it’s a gradual thing like anything else. The difference between a 42-year old guy and a 22-year old one is pretty easy to see, really. You mellow out a little bit. We are open to having a heavier, slower kind of song but when we’re writing we really do try to capture that same aggression that we had at the very beginning. You just have to reach into that part of your mind - it’s still there. It might not be the driving part of you as much as it once was. I mean back then you’re just aggressive. All the time. If I heard one slow song from any of my favourite bands, I was disappointed. ‘Oh, I hate that song, I only like the fast stuff.’ I guess we’ve become, in time, as you mature you open up to having songs at different tempos and things like that.

Overall, it’s going back to that consistency thing, we’ve managed to keep things very consistent and we really do try to harness that original feeling in the songs. If you listen to Demented Aggression or Rabid or Scalding Hail, a lot of the really fast ones we’ve done over the past few years could easily have been songs on our first or second albums. Of course, we’re going to change as people over time. But we’re not going to let it affect our music.

---

Image Source: gunshyassassin.com